The standard financial advice that we all seem to hear when we grow up is something along the lines of work hard so you can buy a house, get a mortgage and sell the house for a profit when you retire. Buying a house as an investment in the future doesn’t fit into my general life philosophy. I think it’s bad, dangerous and incredibly limiting position to be in. Here’s why:
House Prices Don’t Just Go Up
The whole of the reason people buy houses as an investment is based on the assumption that the housing market will only go up. We’ve been lucky in the housing market until recently. House prices have soared. This has meant that people have been willing to take out huge mortgages with little to no deposit, buying houses that they can’t really afford on the assumption that the price will go up. On the face of it, this hasn’t been a bad strategy. The housing market has been booming. Unfortunately, the houses themselves were becoming over valued. This can be understood as a simple case of supply and demand. When house prices go up, speculators build more houses or move to sell properties. This increases supply. Demand won’t be increasing so the prices drop. If you have bought a house at the top of the housing bubble with a 100% mortgage, guess what? You’re now in negative equity. GREAT… naaaat! Negative equity is where you owe more on your house than it’s worth, it’s not a good thing.
A crash in the economy robbed me of my family And no strategy
combats negative equitiy so that’s it. Like violence it’s drastic
I’m freaking’, and seekin’ to be more than just a house of crack
Faithless – Bring My Family Back
Obviously not everyone who buys a house as an investment will end up in negative equity. However, the important point here is that house prices, like any commodity, fluctuate. They are also subject to bubbles and the inevitable burst that accompanies them.
Low Liquidity
Liquidity is a fancy word which means how easily can something be changed into money. A high liquidity asset can be changed, or sold, very quickly. An example for high liquidity would be a FOREX trade lot. This can be sold almost instantaneously. A house, on the other hand, takes much longer. That’s assuming you can sell it in the first place. This doesn’t immediately sound like such a big deal, right? I mean how often do you sell your house? Consider you get the opportunity to take a promotion but the job is the other side of the country. You need to sell your house quickly so you can move, or you don’t take the job. Either way, you lose out. Selling a house quickly means you probably won’t get a good price for it. Not taking the job is obvious really.
On the other hand, if you’d rented, you’d probably only be involved in a 6 month contract at maximum. You could either sub-let or simply move out a few weeks early. Most decent businesses will provide a moving fee. Anyway, compared to losing £1000’s on selling a house for less than it’s worth, losing a couple of months rent isn’t that big a deal. In terms of which is worse, the house always wins.
Diversification
We are constantly advised not to put all our eggs in one basket. I agree totally when it comes to investment. A varied portfolio is important. It puts you in a stronger position financially if your value is spread over a range of assets. Since markets move in cycles and aren’t always aligned, it’s OK to assume that not everything will be going down at the same time. If the weather gets hotter, the sales of jackets decreases but the sale of ice cream increases. If you notice the weather getting warmer you’d be smart to buy ice cream futures (or something like that, I don’t think ice cream is a traded commodity).
With that in mind, if you are spending the vast majority of your money on a mortgage, you can’t spend money diversifying your other assets. This sets you up for failure in the long run. By investing 20 to 30% of your income in mutual funds and other similar types of fund and re-investing the dividends and profits, you will have considerably more money in the long run and these kinds of investments are less likely to be affected by bubbles since they are more diverse. This kind of thing can be set up by a bank easily enough. If you’re a pro investor, there’s no reason you can’t use the money and invest it yourself. It’s easier to let a bank take care of it for you though, if you aren’t a professional entrepreneur.
Low Mobility
Hinted at in the previous post, low mobility is a problem in it’s self. Simply put, you can’t move around as quickly and easily as someone who doesn’t own their own property. Individually, this isn’t always that big an issue. Scale this out across the whole workforce and you do have a problem. The low mobility of a workforce means that it is harder for large scale companies to take advantage of new opportunities.
At an individual level, this means that people can’t always take opportunities that are presented to them. This is a big no no in my world. Failing is OK as far as I’m concerned. What is not OK is missing out on opportunities, especially when it’s due to poor planning on my part.
High Maintenance
Houses take a lot of maintenance. Windows need to be cleaned, damage needs to be fixed, electrics and plumbing need to be kept in order. The list goes on. Anyone who has owned a house will attest to that. In fact, anyone who has lived in a house which they’ve been responsible for will attest to that. I certainly do. Imagine which is better: Maintaining a house yourself or having someone do it for you? That someone is generally the land lord in a rented property. In an owned one, it’s you.
I’ve never lived in rented property where I had to do anything other than pay to change the lightbulb. That’s it! Generally speaking, if you live in a high quality house or apartment, the landlords will make sure it’s kept high quality. That’s how they sell it on after you leave after all. Often this isn’t the case, in terms of student houses for example, where profit is king. The rules of housing don’t apply to students though, everything is different.
Pre Furnished Appartments
Having your own stuff is OK, but it can be a hassle to transport it around. It all has to be accounted for and replaced when it’s damaged. A far better case would be a furnished rental property. The vast majority of rental properties in the UK come furnished. There are some exceptions but in my experience they are few and far between. They’re kind of like Big Foots, I’ve heard rumors that they exist, but I’ve never seen one with my own eyes. Again, the rules of student digs don’t apply to the real world. If you’re only basing your opinion on those types of houses, stop right now and look around at some real properties. You will be amazed at what’s available, I certainly was.
Everyone likes to have their own things, a few ornaments, a comforting bed quilt, an X-Box and HDTV. That’s understandable. Also, those kind of things are usually quite easy to move and can be done with one trip in a car. Unless you have a 56 inch TV that is. (Un)Fortunately, I don’t… yet. When I can afford that sort of luxury, I’ll probably be able to afford to rent a van for the day to help me move too.
Change Of Scenery
So let’s say that you have a good job in a city you like but you’re a bit bored of where you live and fancy a change. This is a whole lot easier if you don’t own your house. It’s also a whole lot more justifiable too. They (the wizards) say that one of the most stressful things you can do is move house. So why make life hard on yourself? It’s far easier just to stay in the same place, the same neighborhood with the same neighbors. Granted, this may not be a bad thing and there’s no timer saying that you need to move house every year or you won’t be happy. However, having the option to move is always a good thing.
The hardest part about changing rented accommodation is finding somewhere cool and new to live. Most agents make this easy for you though. After all, they are trying to sell you a property. They’re probably making a commission. You might as well make them earn it, right? Typically your lease will only be 6 months to a year anyway, why get stuck in the same place for the rest of your life? A change of scenery can lead to a new perspective, especially if you’re feeling a bit stuck in a rut.